What are the red flags in a job interview?

Interviewers who turn up late, eat lunch through the call or ask whether you plan to have kids. What the hiring process looks like from both sides of the table, and what people told us about the interviews that went wrong.

Published
Replies from our community about job interviews that went wrong

What we found

  • Shown the same job ad, a woman sees the 8 out of 10 things she is not qualified for, and a man sees the 2 he meets and applies anyway.
  • Getting past the first screening is harder now, with the number of applications coming through and everyone using AI to tailor them.
  • Once you reach the interview, much of it comes down to trust. The person across the table is staking their own career on you not being a bad hire.
  • Some interviewers still ask about your age, religion, relationship or whether you plan to have kids, which they shouldn't.
  • If a company can't be on its best behaviour for one hour, it is a pretty good preview of what working there would be like.
  • Missing out in the last round often comes down to small differences in what the team is after, and you leave with more interview practice.

The job that got away

Give a man and a woman the same job ad and you’ll get two very different reactions. She’ll see the 8 out of 10 things she’s not qualified for, and he’ll see the 2 requirements he meets and apply anyway. Imposter syndrome is a big one, so if you tick most of what’s on there, just apply. It doesn’t hurt to try, especially as making it past the first screening is way more difficult nowadays with the sheer number of applications coming through and everyone using AI to tailor everything.

Given how many people are unemployed at the moment, making it to the interview is the hardest part. Everything from then on is just the business making sure each buzzword and dot point on your resume is legit and that you’re a fit for the team’s culture. Unless you’ve been in a position to interview candidates, you don’t realise how much of it just comes down to trust. The person on the other side of the table is staking their own career on you not being a bad hire and despite how personal this process always feels, it’s just business.

That’s not to say every interviewer is on their best behaviour. There’s many that turn up late, eat lunch through the call or check their phone while you’re answering. Most of them probably have five interviews back to back. Some will still ask about your age, religion, relationship or whether you’re planning on having kids (which they shouldn’t), and most of us just laugh it off because pushing back could cost us the job. Don’t ever overlook the red flags though. If a company can’t be on its best behaviour for one hour, it’s a pretty good preview of what working for them would be like.

Failing the last round is usually a good thing, even if it doesn’t feel like it at the time. More often than not it comes down to really small differences in what they’re after for their team, so don’t beat yourself up. You’re meant to mirror the people interviewing you, but sometimes it’s just not the right fit, and that’s often a blessing in disguise. You’re probably dodging a bullet, and you’ve picked up more interview practice for the next one.

What did TAC readers tell us?

We asked for your job interview stories. Here is what some of you said.

I did an interview with a IT services organisation about 15 years ago and the interviewer spent the whole interview shopping on his laptop right in-front of me (I initially thought he was taking notes) I could see it in the reflection of the glass door behind him

I had an interview with a mutual bank and the GC asked me about my hobbies and then said “well you won’t have time for those hobbies here”. They also told me they had the lowest NPS score in the company and a real culture problem but then blamed bad employees for bringing the score down

As a 30 year old female I was asked directly by an older male if children were on the cards any time soon - in an interview 😳

Anon pls - Went to interview for a legal counsel/dept manager role that I was sought by a recruiter for. Went through 4 rounds of interviews till I met the local team. Didnt get the role because the local team (HR director) and Legal Counsel admitted they weren't sure what they were looking for, despite regional and recruiter being sure. The role has been up for 5 months and the recruiter reached out to apologise for wasting my time, and acknowledged i would be a great candidate if they could actually decide what they needed. So sloppy it's embarrassing.

I had a partner at a mid tier law firm ask me why I didn’t get HDs in my Masters degree while I was working full time and then reject me because they didn’t think I was passionate enough about insurance....as a graduate

I had a (male) interviewer if I “liked being married”. Super creepy.

I had an interview with a very senior HR executive who at the end of the interview shook my hand and said you know within the first couple of minutes if you’re going to hire them or not I proceeded to then not get the job.

Eating their lunch while interviewing me for a process that had already been going for 4 months

Source: The Aussie Corporate reader replies, November 2026. Spotted an error? Correct something.

Read the full Flat White edition