Tenants renting through agents faced more than double the likelihood of reporting common tenancy problems relative to those who rented directly from landlords, according to new research using the Australian Housing Conditions Dataset, SBS News reported.
The research drew on a large-scale nationally representative survey covering over 12,000 households in private rentals. Only renters with a formal lease who had occupied their property for a minimum of one year were included in the analysis. Agents rather than landlords manage approximately 80% of privately rented homes across Australia.
Over one third of private renters reported a delay in repairs or maintenance. Nearly 29% reported a restriction on how they used their home, while nearly one in five reported experiencing an unjustified rent increase.
These differences held after adjusting for property type, household characteristics and location. The same tenancy laws apply whether a property is managed by an agent or directly by a landlord.
The researchers noted that agents prioritise keeping landlords' business over retaining tenants, particularly when rental markets are tight and vacancy rates are low. Agents often handle large numbers of properties by following standard procedures, which can reduce opportunities for tenants to negotiate individual arrangements, the researchers said. Some agencies actively discourage or prohibit direct contact between landlords and tenants.
Agents play roles including selecting tenants, coordinating repairs, and setting and adjusting rents. They are engaged and retained by landlords but are typically the primary or only point of contact for tenants. The researchers said improved agent training in renter communication, problem resolution and understanding the impact of management decisions could benefit both tenants and landlords, alongside clear standards and accountability.
Renters who deal with an agent rather than directly with a landlord face a substantially higher likelihood of experiencing delayed repairs, unjustified rent increases and restrictions on how they use their home. Those who deal directly with a landlord may have more scope to negotiate individual arrangements.
Reporting: SBS News, The Conversation
Written by Pick & Scroll News from the reporting and documents linked above.

